Investments driven by the desire to contribute to society or the planet are becoming increasingly popular in India. ESG mutual funds enable exactly this. The portfolio includes companies that are mindful of their environmental impact, treat their employees fairly, and are governed with integrity.
ESG mutual funds in India are increasingly attracting investors who want their money to reflect their values alongside delivering returns. For anyone considering an ESG SIP in India, one question is worth asking before the first instalment goes in. Is the fund actually doing what the label says, or is it a familiar set of large cap companies dressed in sustainable packaging?
What ESG Actually Means for Stock Selection in India
ESG stands for Environmental, Social and Governance, three dimensions that together determine whether a company qualifies for inclusion in the fund's portfolio.
The environmental criteria examines how a company manages its carbon footprint, water usage and waste. Social criteria looks at employee welfare programs, workplace safety and community engagement. Governance examines board composition, executive accountability and the company's ethical track record.
The ESG screening process has become more structured since SEBI made BRSR (Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting) reporting mandatory in India for the top 1,000 listed companies, giving fund managers access to standardised sustainability data that simply did not exist three years ago."
However the quality of ESG assessment still varies significantly across fund houses. Two funds carrying the same ESG label can hold very different portfolios depending on how stringently each applies the criteria.
SEBI ESG Fund Regulations: What They Require and What They Miss
SEBI classifies ESG funds under the thematic equity mutual fund category. At least 80% of the fund's assets must be invested in companies that align with its stated ESG strategy. The strategy, whether it excludes certain sectors or factors ESG scores alongside financial metrics, must be clearly disclosed in the ESG fund's Scheme Information Document, which every investor should read before committing capital.
Each asset management company is permitted to offer only one ESG scheme. This limits the market to fewer, higher quality products rather than allowing fund houses to launch multiple offerings that carry the ESG label without the substance behind it. Fund houses are also required to disclose their ESG evaluation criteria and exclusions transparently, a step SEBI introduced specifically to address greenwashing.
Also read: Why Too Much Variety Is Diluting Your Investment Growth
The Problem With the Label: ESG Greenwashing in India
SEBI's regulations are a step in the right direction, but they do not guarantee that every ESG fund is actually serving the purpose its label suggests.
Several ESG funds in India exhibit a similar pattern. Infosys, HDFC Bank, TCS, Reliance Industries. These large cap names dominate their portfolios. Even after applying the ESG screen, the output looks remarkably similar to a standard diversified equity fund.
The reason is straightforward. India's ESG disclosure ecosystem is still developing. The companies with the most comprehensive and reliable ESG data tend to be the larger, better governed ones, which are also the ones that dominate large cap indices anyway. Fund managers are not cutting corners by defaulting to these names. They are simply working with the most reliable data available.
But for the investor, the practical question becomes uncomfortable. If an ESG fund looks just like a large cap fund, what justifies paying a higher expense ratio for the ESG label?
Before committing SIPs to an ESG fund, checking the actual top 10 holdings and comparing them against a standard large cap fund reveals the degree of ESG fund portfolio overlap, and whether the fund is genuinely differentiated or simply a large cap fund with a sustainable wrapper.
***Your Quick Guide to Investing in Mutual Funds on Tradejini ***
What ESG Fund Returns in India Actually Show
The greenwashing concern is real, but it also raises a question. What level of competitive returns are ESG funds actually able to deliver?
Over the past two to five years, ESG funds have delivered competitive returns. Axis ESG Equity Fund, HDFC ESG Equity Fund and Mirae Asset ESG Fund have all performed in line with regular equity funds. But most of these funds launched around 2020. The time frame is simply not long enough to judge whether ESG funds outperform, underperform or match the market over a full cycle.
This period does help us understand one thing clearly. Being ESG screened does not handicap returns. But it also does not guarantee outperformance. What creates an edge is a combination of the ESG screen itself, the fund manager's skill in stock picking, and disciplined portfolio construction working together.
This distinction matters because many investors come to ESG funds expecting both conscience and outsized returns. Reality requires realigning expectations. Competitive returns in line with regular equity funds is the honest promise. The premium comes from values alignment, not from superior financial performance.
Also read: Thinking of Stopping Your SIP? Read This First
Who Should Invest in an ESG Fund
ESG funds are not suitable for every investor or every portfolio.
It makes sense for someone whose values align with the concept of ESG, who has the bandwidth to stay invested for six to ten years, and who is willing to examine actual portfolio changes rather than simply trusting the fund name. An ESG SIP in India works best as a satellite allocation within a broader equity portfolio rather than the core holding.
It cannot be a default choice made simply to feel like a responsible investor. If the ESG criteria do not resonate personally, or if the investment horizon is shorter, a regular diversified fund is the more appropriate choice.
ESG investing demands more homework than regular fund investing. Going through the actual holdings, checking the fund house's ESG screening methodology, and reviewing the exclusion list are what separate real impact from greenwashing. The label alone does not do that work.
The Bottom Line
ESG funds in India are maturing. Regulations are tighter and disclosures have improved, but the overlap with regular large cap funds remains real.
The question for an investor is not whether ESG funds are worth it in principle. It is whether the specific fund chosen actually reflects what the label claims and whether it aligns with personal values and investment horizon.
Disclaimer: The information provided in our blogs is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, investment, or trading advice. Trading and investing in the securities market carries risk. Always conduct your own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Copyrighted and original content for your trading and investing needs.
© 2026 — Tradejini. All Rights Reserved.
